Where William Wouldn't Take No For an Answer

The Conqueror by Georgette Heyer
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This is a good book, one well worth reading, even though it took me quite a while to work through it. Rating it for fun, I'd lean more 3, due to some pacing issues (IMO). But there's more to this novel than entertainment. For historical scholarship, its finely crafted setting, its welcome complexity, and a very educational narrative, I'd give it a 4 at least.

I know Heyer mostly from her Regency romances, the books I was sent to when I asked other lovers of Jane Austen what author they thought wrote most like Austen. Since then, I've read maybe 9 or 10 of them, and I've enjoyed them collectively more than I originally expected. I've also read a mystery or two of hers, and I'd say those were okay; I'm not a huge fan of country estate murder mysteries, though I'll read one here and there. What I didn't know until now was that Heyer wrote straight-up historical novels. That's what this is. There's no more than a touch of romance here, and there's no mystery at all. There are women, and lovers, and love stories found in these pages, but this is book is closer to a biography of William the Conqueror. Told mostly from the perspective of Raoul, one of his closest supporters, the book covers about 20 years of William's life, ending shortly after the invasion of 1066.

(Hope that's not a spoiler.)

The beginning wasn't what I expected. Grimmer, maybe. The focus seemed odd. (This was all my fault, btw.) Even 50 or 100 pages in, I started to think the book would turn out to be a romance (of the bodice-ripping, chest-heaving, raven-haired tresses sort that I don't have much interest in), with a melodramatic tone and low stakes. But no. This is a no-nonsense historical novel with a very serious tone and heavy themes. It's about war and battles and strategy and putting down rebellions. It's about friendship and trust and honor and keeping one's word. It's about a man driven to make his mark on history and the people who gradually learned to believe in him, trust him, and follow him, helping him go from a beleaguered warlord to the leader of a stable regional power to the sovereign of a whole nation.

It was pretty fun to read, but not super fun. I didn't relish every page. However, there is nothing I could point to and say should have been edited out or abridged, and overall I'm glad I read it. Yes, I wish it moved a little quicker or varied in tone a bit more, but maybe it's better this way--leaning more toward an educational work of scholarship. This is no textbook, though; it's a novel, and I think a good one. Perhaps the greatest pleasure I've gotten from it is having a fuller picture of the historical setting and the Norman Invasion, filling in a picture that has been very sketchy most of my life.

So, yes, recommended.

View all my reviews

Where Reacher Hunts an American in Germany

Night School by Lee Child
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I liked it quite a bit. I found this one more rewarding to pick back up than the first couple I've read; either it's a little better or I'm more in the groove with the series.

Reacher is a good character, and I feel like Lee Child uses him well. He's not unstoppable or a super genius, but he's good at the things that an investigator should be good at--like reading witnesses and guessing how a suspect might be thinking and getting ahead of them--and he's especially good at not getting beat up by a random bad guy. And he's not just good at that; the author uses those things in the plot. You can count on him to come out on top in most hand-to-hand encounters, which so far are found in every novel I've looked at.

(I point this out because I've read a few books lately where the main characters are supposed to be good at something but then we don't see it much or at all in the story. Sherlock has got to see clues nobody else sees. Elizabeth Bennet has to say witty things. Captain Kirk better win against the odds. And Reacher needs to show out. He's a good investigator, so he's gonna figure some stuff out in a clever way, and he's a great big guy who can fight, so he better be fighting somebody or I'm gonna be disappointed.) ;)

This novel is set earlier in his career when he was still in the army, and I found that difference interesting. He had to work with a number of people instead of just doing everything his way, and he had to restrain himself in some cases. The constraints made him have to be even more creative than usual, and I think it made the plot work.

I thought it was pretty fun. 4 stars.

View all my reviews

Where It's Nine Hibiscus's Story

A Desolation Called Peace by Arkady Martine
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This is a good book, in a lot of ways, which I was expecting; the first book was really great. But even though I mostly enjoyed reading this, the flaws and bad decisions (as always, in my opinion) nearly overshadowed everything else. This was a four, but a disappointing four, which is my rarest score...

Arkady Martine is a wonderful writer of prose. Sentence by sentence, paragraph by paragraph, cool idea by cool idea, she is great writer. Her style is brisk and entertaining, even when little is happening, and that kept me coming back.

But.

Okay, for one thing: Eight antidote, the little kid who will be the next emperor, is just a really boring character. Every time the POV switched to him, the book slowed to a crawl. At the very end, the author gave him something cool to do, an interesting bit of action, and that almost redeems the long, dull pages filled with trivial nothings. Except no, it doesn't. Almost every page devoted to him, except the last handful, could have been simply cut to improve the pacing a ton without losing anything.

Worse, Mahit Dzmare is supposedly the main character, but she's entirely forgettable and pointless in this novel. She's there for a lot of the action, like a fly on the wall or a purse under someone's arm, but she contributes almost nothing. She's spoken of and treated like she's brilliant and special and remarkable, but the author gives her nothing brilliant or remarkable to do. Three Seagrass drags her along on this war adventure, and everything they accomplish could have been done by Three Seagrass alone. Except for their love scenes, obviously. I wanted the Mahit we had in the first book, and she just wasn't here.

The real main character is Nine Hibiscus, the fleet commander, and she is interesting. If the book had been just about her, leaving Mahit out of it entirely, it would have made more sense. She makes a sort of Jean Luc Picard series of decisions, and that was the best part of the book.

If you want an action story with movement and brisk pacing, it's a bit hit-or-miss. If you were looking for spectacle, which an interstellar war promises, you'll get very little, hardly more than a few scattered pages. If you want to see your favorite MC be awesome, you'll have to squint, because it's kinda there, but it's more suggested than shown. But if you read the book for fine prose, or for ideas on language and identity, or for themes such as sacrifice and nationality and cultural hegemony, you'll probably be rewarded.

View all my reviews

Where They Should Just Wake Up

Slightly Married by Mary Balogh
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Pretty good. I still like the book and the author, but this is my least favorite of her novels so far. 3 stars.

I liked Aidan and Eve--by the very end. But it took me a long time to warm up to them (and them to each other). They were admirable all the way through. Honorable. Good people, trying to do the right thing. But I didn't care much about them. Both of them were so cold to each other, outwardly, anyway, and formal, and uncommunicative. It wore me out. In the other books I've read by Mary Balogh, I liked and enjoyed and rooted for the main characters almost from the beginning, and that didn't happen here. (Could have been me, obviously.)

Aidan promises a dying soldier to protect his sister, Eve. He brings her the news of his death and discovers by a quirk of their family's will that she will lose everything if she isn't married by a certain date--in about a week. Because Eve makes a home for servants who have been cast off by the world and a pair of orphaned children that she is more or less parent to, it is not just for herself but for their sakes she wants to keep her home and property. So... Aidan marries her, promising to leave her alone as soon as the wedding is over. Problem solved!

Complications arise, obviously. Everyone learns about the marriage, and they have to follow through on more than just saying "I do." They hang out, and she meets his family and wins them over. But both of them think, until almost the end, that the other one wants to be left alone to go back to their regular, single life once everything is done. He thinks she does; she thinks he does. Even though they have been growing closer during all this time together, learning to admire and care for one another, they keep that feeling hidden. Really hidden. Smashed down deep. A smidge of communication could have fixed this much sooner.

It ends well, and I almost gave it a 4, but 3 is right--it was good, good enough to read and recommend to people who like this type of story.

View all my reviews

Where Joliffe Goes to Rouen

A Play of Treachery by Margaret Frazer
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

A good book. It has some quirks, maybe flaws, but I still enjoyed reading it.

This series has been very entertaining, but this book took a turn, and it almost didn't work for me. Joliffe has been with his traveling troupe of actors in the first four, solving mysteries while they're putting on plays in rich houses or village greens. Here, he gets hired to go to France (to Rouen, in the part England still governed back then) to serve in a rich household and learn how to be a spy, basically. It's a good idea, opening up cool possibilities for the series, but it takes a lot of time.

It makes this a sort of hybrid book--training for a job first and solving a mystery second. In fact, probably 2/3 or 3/4 of the book is about Joliffe learning how to be a spy while pretending to be a kind of losery drunk guy who's about to get fired. He trains in spycraft and weapons in the night while working as a scribe and watching everybody during the day. All this is fine--but it's meant to be a mystery series and the first part isn't all that fun. It isn't until quite near the end that we get a mystery, which is where it gets good. (I was gonna give it a 3 until that point.) There's a murder and an attempted murder, and at last Joliffe is doing his thing, bringing his skills to bear.

I guess the author wanted to give Joliffe more scope for those skills, and I agree with the idea. I expect the next novel jumps into the action quicker.

It's still a brisk read, even the early parts, and by the end it's quite fun. Recommended--in order.

View all my reviews

Where Mack Bolan Surprises the Bad Guys

Mountain Rampage by Don Pendleton
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I thought this was a better-than-average example of the genre.

The early Mack Bolan books are all about him taking on mafia families in various cities, getting revenge for his loved ones. Somewhere along the line, he pivoted to terrorists and the like. I haven't read enough or researched it to know when that happened, but this one (#54) is an example of the latter. The formula still works, IMO, and the book is an entertaining read.

The whole idea for the series is that there are criminals and evildoers who are so brutal, so dangerous and evil, that we can have no sympathy for them at all, so we can root for Bolan doing whatever he has to do to stop them. He's Rambo, John Wick, Doc Savage, and Ethan Hunt all wrapped into one. Here, his target is a bunch of eastern European (communist) terrorists who are preparing to poison whole cities, and they have been testing their chemicals on kidnapped people. He has to go into their Rocky Mountain compound all alone and stop them.

It's very satisfying in a kinda gladiatorial way when he kills the people we've seen commit horrendous crimes and then rescues some survivors. It's all very unlikely--one against 50--but the author actually does a reasonable job of imagining how it could be possible, provided the man is athletic, quick, and a very good shot. Resourceful, too. He cheats, though; he doesn't let them know he's coming.

These books are not for everybody, but I've liked them so far, and this one was one of the more satisfying ones of the books I've sampled. I'm a little surprised how much fun I find them, actually. It helps that they're move like novellas than novels. It's as if someone took a 100,000 page novel and removed everything but the action.

Nope. Not as if. That's exactly it. :)

View all my reviews

Another Graustark Adventure

Beverly of Graustark by George Barr McCutcheon
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Not really a 4--but more fun than most 3's. 3.5, IMO.

I rather like this book and this series, despite a number of criticisms any reader could easily make. It's not very serious, mostly silly melodrama, and reads a little cartoony. It's coming from outdated turn-of-the-century (120+ years ago, I mean) sensibilities--putting me in mind of early Hollywood. In fact, the whole time I was reading this, I kept imagining it as a very old epic filmed on a soundstage with cheesy costumes, stilted dialogue, and lame sets. That's not a criticism, though, but rather my opinion about the best way to approach this book. You have to let it be a bit over-the-top.

Like the Zenda books, this series is about a fictional small country in Eastern Europe. In the previous book, an American man married the princess of the country, and in this one, a Southern woman, a friend of the princess, visits Graustark and falls in love with a man from neighboring Dawbergen. He isn't what he seems--then he is--then he isn't. You don't know until the last couple pages who he actually is. But Beverly and Baldos fall in love while he is hiding from partisans trying to overthrow the rightful prince of his country. I don't think I could put up with Beverly in real life. Her game playing--pretending not to care about Baldos, then showing him a little attention, followed again by studied neglect--was annoying, but treated like just what women do.

Overall, it's a light adventure, or maybe a cozy romance, with pretty low stakes and a happy ending. It's pretty fun, and though it suffers from many of the outdated attitudes of the time, it's entertaining and silly, and readers might be able to overlook its flaws just enough to be amused by its melodrama.

View all my reviews