Once Upon a Thriller by Carolyn KeeneMy rating: 4 of 5 stars
This is one of the books from the modern incarnation of the Nancy Drew series, dating to the 2010s--these are "The Nancy Drew Diaries"--and I thought it worked very well. Though it's aimed at a middle-grade audience, I still found it smart and winning, a pleasant cozy mystery for when you're not looking for too much suspense and tension.
Like most any long-running book series (such as Star Trek or The Shadow or Reacher but not Goosebumps), a large part of the pleasure is returning to a familiar character or group of characters, jumping straight in to the action without lots of introductions. (Goosebumps has new characters each time, like The Twilight Zone or something, and though it loses out on that, it does benefit from having a familiar style and tone for returning readers. Maybe that's enough sometimes.) You still want a good plot, but if you're a fan of the series you're probably predisposed to enjoying the book from the start, hanging out in a favorite space with familiar characters.
The plot here is pretty straightforward without any great excitement or amazing twists, and I'll admit it's not terribly memorable, but it doesn't need to be. It's complete, it's logical, it has minor scrapes and scares, it has clues to gather and tally, and as a mystery it works. IMO, it has enough going on to suit a fan and lead them on to the next book.
I think young readers especially would still enjoy this and the rest of the series. I found it looking brand new at the dollar store, even though it's probably been in a box for 12 or 13 years. It still sounds current, anyway. Scoring on how much I think a young reader would like it (instead of how much I liked it, which is my usual criterion, even though I actually liked it alright) I think it's a solid 4.
I wonder if they're reprinting these. Probably all over eBay, anyway.
View all my reviews





